AUTHORITIES,
practice. By this word is understood the citations which are made of
laws, acts of the legislature, and decided cases, and opinions of
elementary writers. In its more confined sense, this word means, cases
decided upon solemn argument which are said to 'be authorities for
similar judgments iii like cases. 1 Lilly's Reg. 219. These latter are
sometimes called precedents. (q. v.) Merlin, Repertoire, mot Autorites.
2.
It has been remarked, that when we find an opinion in a text writer
upon any particular point, we must consider it not merely as the opinion
of the author, but as the supposed result of the authorities to which
he refers; 3 Bos. & Pull. 361; but this is not always the case, and
frequently the opinion is advanced with the reasons which support it,
and it must stand or fall as these are or are not well founded. A
distinction has been made between writers who have, and those who have
not holden a judicial station; the former are considered authority, and
the latter are not so considered unless their works have been judicially
approved as such. Ram. on Judgments, 93. But this distinction appears
not to be well founded; some writers who have occupied a judicial
station do not possess the talents or the learning of others who have
not been so elevated, and the works or writings of the latter are much
more deserving the character of an authority than those of the former.
See 3 T. R. 4, 241.
No comments:
Write comments