ERROR. A mistake in judgment or deviation from the truth, in matters of fact and from the law in matters of judgment.
2.
- 1 Error of fact. The law has wisely provide that a person shall be
excused, if, intending to do a lawful act, and pursuing lawful means to
accomplish his object, he commit an act which would be criminal or
unlawful, if it were done with a criminal design or in an unlawful
manner; for example, thieves break into my house, in the night time, to
commit a burglary; I rise out of my bed, and seeing a person with a
drawn sword running towards my wife, I take him for one of
the burglars, and shoot him down, and afterwards find he was one of my friends, whom, owing to the dimness of the light, I could not recognize, who had lodged with me, rose on the first alarm, and was in fact running towards my wife, to rescue her from the hands of an assassin; still I am innocent, because I committed an error as to a fact, which I could not know, and had, no time to inquire about.
the burglars, and shoot him down, and afterwards find he was one of my friends, whom, owing to the dimness of the light, I could not recognize, who had lodged with me, rose on the first alarm, and was in fact running towards my wife, to rescue her from the hands of an assassin; still I am innocent, because I committed an error as to a fact, which I could not know, and had, no time to inquire about.
3.
Again, a contract made under a clear error is not binding; as, if the
seller and purchaser of a house situated in Now York, happen to be in
Philadelphia, and, at the time of the sale, it was unknown to both
parties that the house was burned down, there will be no valid contract;
or if I sell you my horse Napoleon, which we both suppose to be in my
stable, and at the time of the contract he is dead, the sale is void. 7
How. Miss. R. 371 3 Shepl. 45; 20 Wend. 174; 9 Shepl. 363 2 Brown, 27; 5
Conn. 71; 6 Mass. 84; 12 Mass. 36. See Sale.
4.
Courts of equity will in general correct and rectify all errors in fact
committed in making deeds and contracts founded on good considerations.
See Mistake.
5.
- 2. Error in law. As the law is, or which is the same thing, is
presumed to be certain and definite, every man is bound to understand
it, and an error of law will not, in general, excuse a man, for its
violation.
6.
A contract made under an error in law, is in general binding, for were
it not so, error would be urged in almost every case. 2 East, 469; see 6
John. Ch. R. 166 8 Cowen, 195; 2 Jac. & Walk. 249; 1 Story, Eq.
Jur. 156; 1 Younge & Coll. 232; 6 B. & C. 671 Bowy. Com. 135; 3
Sav. Dr. Rom. App. viii. But a foreign law will for this purpose be
considered as a fact. 3 Shepl. 45; 9 Pick. 112; 2 Ev. Pothier, 369,
&c. See, also, Ignorance; Marriage; Mistake.
7.
By error, is also understood a mistake made in the trial of a cause, to
correct which a writ of error may be sued out of a superior court.
ERROR, WRIT OF.
A writ of error is one issued fro a superior to an inferior court, for
the purpose of bringing up the record and correcting an alleged error
committed in the trial in the court below. But it cannot deliver the
body from prison. Bro. Abr. Acc. pl. 45. The judges to whom the writ is
directed have no power to return the record nisi judicium inde redditum
sit. Nor can it be brought except on the final judgment. See Metcalf's
Case, 11 Co. Rep. 38, which is eminently instructive on this subject.
Vide Writ of Error.
No comments:
Write comments